Home > Latest News > Ian Stebbings secures Claimant’s discontinuance by successful collateral waiver of privilege argument.


Ian Stebbings secures Claimant’s discontinuance by successful collateral waiver of privilege argument.




The Claimant alleged that he had fallen over a temporary road sign. In his CNF he alleged that the time of the accident was 7pm. In his witness statement and Part 18 responses he stated that the accident was between 4-5pm. The timing was crucial as the Defendants did not put any temporary signs out until 6.30pm. Two days before trial the Claimants solicitors sought to adduce both a witness statement and a manuscript document which were the solicitors notes of the original conference which gave rise to the timing on the CNF. They made an application for late inclusion of the witness statement and the manuscript document. Defence Counsel, Mr. Stebbings, made an application at the trial that the disclosure of the privileged material was a collateral waiver of privilege and therefore any other privilege documents which went to the issue in question (the timings) were also disclosable. The District Judge agreed and stated he would make such an order for disclosure. Claimant’s Counsel sought time to take instructions and upon return discontinued the claim.

Ian Stebbings acted on behalf of Keoghs, Instructing Solicitors

Latest Stop Press Read more


Trecarrel House Limited v Rouncefield

20th February 2019

This article was first published in Nearly Legal

HHJ Carr in a reserved judgment handed down on 13 Feb 2019 allowed the Appellant’s appeal against a possession order made by DDJ Rutherford in the Truro County Court on 13 Sept 2018.

The tenancy was an AST granted 20 Feb 2017 of a...

Read more

ABTA The Travel Law Seminar 22-23 May 2019

19th February 2019

We're delighted to announce that Sarah Prager will, again, be speaking at the ABTA Travel Law Seminar. To see the other speakers and programme, click here

Read more