Home > Latest News > Goman v Stockport MBC


Goman v Stockport MBC




Probation officers and social workers did not owe a duty of care to warn a woman of her partner’s past history of domestic violence. HHJ Sephton QC so held in Goman v Stockport MBC, judgment 20 March 2018. The case is thought to have to been the first claim against social workers to have been tried following the Court of Appeal’s recent decision in CN v Poole. The Judge rejected an argument that the Supreme Court’s decision in Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police implicitly overruled CN v Poole; on the contrary the application of ordinary common law principles (as endorsed in Robinson) led to the conclusion that no duty of care was owed. The Judge further rejected a claim under the Human Rights Act 1998, holding that the high threshold for liability under that Act was not met. He also held that the Claimant and her daughter had not established that the giving of an earlier warning would have prevented the assaults in respect of which they sued.

Andrew Warnock QC, instructed by BLM, represented Stockport MBC

Latest Stop Press Read more


Miller v The Metropolitan Police

13th December 2018

Katie Ayres successfully defended the Metropolitan Police Commissioner in a multi-day Jury Trial before His Honour Judge Saggerson.

The Claimant, Mr Miller, brought claims for assault, false imprisonment and malicious prosecution against the Met Police arising out of an incident at a protest...

Read more

Inquest touching the death of Nigel Thomas Handscomb

4th December 2018

This article was first published in the November AvMA newsletter.

Nigel Handscomb was a 65 year old gentleman with a history of bipolar disorder, which was managed well with lithium. On the 18th August 2017, Mr Handscomb visited his GP surgery, presenting with a history of dysphagia and vomiting...

Read more